by qv » April 22nd, 2012, 12:30 pm
[quote="Jeshi"][quote="PowerHoden"][quote="Jeshi"]While there are many times when people are hypnotized without specifically wanting to (through surprise triggers and the such), I don't know of any times when someone has gone under when they very specifically did not want to. That tends to be how hypnosis works, you can get people to do things they would otherwise be indifferent to (such as silly things that they'd have no reason not to do, but no reason to do either) but not things that they'd object to.
For me, even if I've "tried to resist" I've always really be willing deep down, just "resisting" to make it more fun. Sometimes though people have tried and failed because they were so bad at it that even if they used a trigger my brain would just decide that they were too stupid for it to work.[/quote]
The point is how you define "specifically don't want to"?
He might don't want to in general but is not aware of beeing hypnotised because of a lack of knowledge.
For example there is a case from spain where a hypnotiseur robbed a market because he hypnotized the cashier.[/quote]
There's a lot of those stories where robbers "hypnotize people" and so far I don't really know if they should be believes or not. It's very likely that someone stole the money themselves then blamed it on some made-up "hypnotist robber" or something. That way they didn't have control over it and can't be blamed.
The way you can tell if someone was okay with doing something or not before they were hypnotized, is that if they did it they were okay with it on some level. When people are told to do things that they really don't want to do, then they don't do them. They either ignore the suggestion or snap awake.
The same goes for being hypnotized. If they're actually really not at all okay with being hypnotized, if they aren't cooperating, then the inductions won't work.[/quote]
...eeehhhhhhh, for those with healthy personal boundaries, yeah. But most people aren't very in-tune with their subconscious minds... to the extent that their subconscious doesn't really even know how to think for itself. Possibly thanks to suggestions to be blank, obedient, etc., I don't know.
I just mean that if a person isn't sure what to believe, it's simply a matter of getting them to believe they want to be used. Not a healthy worldview by any stretch of the imagination, which normally should get picked up on by the subconscious, but, work in sufficient trauma...
Then, of course, there's the matter of fact that people can enter trance out of reflex, thinking or not. That's sometimes the point of triggers: you don't want a subject thinking about it, you want them doing it. If you sink in a trigger deep enough, you may very well make it reflexive, whether desired at the moment or not. Consider the warnings about operating heavy machinery, for instance: there have been legitimate cases where people trance in unhealthy situations, seemingly without considering the danger of the situation. They may want to be hypnotized, but I would sure hope none would actually be 'willing' to trance if it means lives may be on the line.
...so as for the question "Can people be taken under against their will", yes, though semantically it comes down to the fact that will can be shaped more than anything. That, and reflexive response... if you see a guy masturbating, are you willing to get hard? Or is it even a matter of will at this point?
Q.E.D.